Mineral Wool vs Fiberglass:Which one is better?

1/2/20246 min read

In our increasingly noisy world, creating quiet and comfortable living and working spaces is crucial. Insulating materials play a key role in soundproofing, offering compelling reasons to enhance the acoustics of homes, offices, or commercial settings. The recognition of sound pollution's negative impacts on health, such as hearing impairment and cardiovascular issues, has heightened the importance of soundproofing.

Mineral wool and fiberglass stand out as prominent soundproofing materials, providing effective thermal insulation and contributing significantly to acoustic treatments. While both materials offer benefits, they come with distinct advantages and disadvantages. This exploration aims to compare the characteristics of mineral wool and fiberglass, aiding in the selection of the most suitable product for room acoustics or soundproofing projects.

Fiberglass Wool

Shenzhou Glass Wool Board

Shenzhou Glass Wool Blanket

Shenzhou Glass Wool Board With Foil

Shenzhou Glass Wool Blanket With Foil

Houswool® Environment Friendly Glass Wool

Fructose Based Eco Friendly Glass Wool

SHENZHOU® Formaldehyde Free Glass Wool

Shenzhou Glass Wool Pipe

Mineral wool boasts intrinsic qualities such as:

Noise Reduction:
- Mineral wool effectively attenuates sound, contributing to a quieter and more comfortable indoor environment.
Fire Resistance:
- With inherent resistance to high temperatures, mineral wool enhances safety by acting as a fire-resistant barrier.
Protection Against Fungi, Mold, and Bacteria:
- Its composition and structure make mineral wool resistant to the growth of fungi, mold, and bacteria, promoting a healthier living or working space.
Durability:
- Mineral wool exhibits a robust and enduring nature, ensuring long-lasting performance and sustained effectiveness.

However, it's essential to consider the following factors before opting for mineral wool installation:

Weight:
- Mineral wool is relatively heavier compared to some alternative insulation materials, necessitating careful consideration of structural implications during installation.
Cost:
- While providing a range of benefits, mineral wool tends to be relatively more expensive to purchase initially, requiring a thoughtful evaluation of budget considerations.

Home

About Shenzhou

Cooperation Case

Technology Center

What is Mineral Wool？

Mineral wool, encompassing variations such as rock wool or slag wool, represents a category of insulation materials derived from either rock and stone or a blend of various metals. The manufacturing process involves subjecting the raw materials to intense heat, causing them to melt and transform into fibers. These fibers are then intricately spun to create what is commonly referred to as "wool." The next step involves layering these fibers into sizable sheets, which are stacked atop each other. The result is a mattress-like, fibrous material, typically exhibiting hues of pale yellow or beige. The final product is available in a semi-rigid or compressed form, offering versatility in its application.

Mineral Wool Advantages＆Disadvantages

Fiberglass Advantages＆Disadvantages

Fiberglass insulation is a popular choice owing to its several advantages, including:

Easy Installation:
- Installation is straightforward, particularly when there are no obstructions like electrical boxes between studs and joists.
Fire Resistance:
- Fiberglass exhibits fire-resistant properties, contributing to enhanced safety in buildings.
Cost Effectiveness:
- It is a cost-effective insulation option, making it accessible for a wide range of construction projects.
Light Weight:
- Fiberglass insulation's lightweight nature simplifies handling and installation processes.
Wide Availability:
- Widely accessible in the market, fiberglass insulation is readily available for various construction and insulation needs.
Recycled Sources:
- Some fiberglass products are manufactured using recycled materials, aligning with sustainability goals.

However, it's essential to consider the following limitations when opting for fiberglass insulation:

Vulnerability to Moisture:
- Fiberglass is susceptible to moisture, necessitating the use of sealed batts or an additional protective barrier to prevent potential issues related to dampness.
Efficiency Reduction Over Time:
- The insulation efficiency of fiberglass may decrease over time as the material sags, impacting its overall thermal performance. Regular maintenance and proper installation are crucial to mitigate this drawback.

What is Fiberglass Wool?

Fiberglass stands as another prominent insulation material, primarily derived from sand and glass. The fabrication process shares similarities with that of mineral wool. However, in the final stages of production, a polymer glue is sprayed onto the material, imparting the classic pink, cotton-candy appearance for which fiberglass is well-known. This polymer coating enhances the overall structural integrity of the fiberglass insulation, contributing to its versatility and widespread use in various applications.

Mineral Wool VS Fiberglass:Sound insulation performance comparison

In terms of soundproofing capabilities, the consensus among experts leans towards the superiority of mineral wool, also known as stone wool, when compared to fiberglass. This advantage is attributed to mineral wool's higher density, resulting in a superior Sound Transmission Class (STC) rating. Mineral wool typically boasts an STC rating ranging from 45 to 52, positioning it as the insulation material with the highest soundproofing capabilities. In contrast, fiberglass tends to have a lower STC rating. For instance, incorporating fiberglass insulation into a standard wall with an STC of 33 only marginally elevates the collective rating to 39.

Therefore, if soundproofing is a primary consideration, especially in settings such as office spaces or commercial venues, mineral wool emerges as a preferable choice due to its exceptional STC rating and superior density.

R-Value and Heat Insulation

When pitted against fiberglass batts, mineral wool batts showcase a notable edge in insulation performance, boasting approximately a 22-37% higher R-value per inch. This enhanced thermal resistance makes mineral wool an advantageous choice for various applications. In commercial settings, the relatively higher cost associated with soundproofing using rockwool insulation may be justified by the substantial benefits it offers in terms of thermal regulation. The improved insulation can lead to reduced heating and air conditioning expenses over time, contributing to potential long-term cost savings.

However, it's crucial to consider the scale of the project, particularly in large facilities like warehouses. The need for a significant quantity of insulation in such expansive spaces may contribute to a notable increase in overall project costs. As such, while the benefits of mineral wool insulation, including superior R-value and soundproofing capabilities, are evident, careful consideration of the specific project requirements and budget constraints is essential to make an informed decision.

How should i choose？

Based on our comparisons above, mineral wool is a far superior product in many ways. It has a higher STC rating, R-value, and melting point. But a significant drawback for many is its cost. Mineral wool is also a lot heavier, so it’s worth considering if you’re planning a DIY project at home and plan on using mineral wool, especially to insulate a ceiling or roof. There are many cases where using either material would get the job done and done well. But there are exceptions and situations when one is better than the other. For example, mineral wool is much more commonly used on exterior installations, primarily because of its hydrophobic quality. Fiberglass is more widely used on interior installations, such as walls, attics, basements, and garages. But whichever you choose, both are great products and, if installed correctly, will be a great addition to any space.